Editorial: No more musical beds

On Tuesday, we commented here on the ongoing overcrowding crisis in California prisons and concluded that our prison system is failing.

That failure is cast in sharp relief by the demand from federal court judges that the population in the state’s prison cells be further reduced to a level of about 110,000 prisoners. That level, if achieved, will still leave the prison population at 137.5 percent of capacity, a degree of overcrowding the courts consider “humane.” Design capacity, as of January 2011, was 83,981.

On Wednesday, the legislature adopted a solution to the immediate constitutional crisis by agreeing to a compromise between opposing plans promoted by Gov. Jerry Brown, along with most legislative leaders, and Senate President Pro Tem Darrell Steinberg. Brown’s plan called for spending $315 million on “additional capacity” (read, renting prison space out of state, in county jails or in to-be-built private cells in California). Steinberg’s plan called for investing $200 million a year in increased resources for ex-con intervention to keep them from coming back at the current recidivism rate of about 58 percent, the second-highest rate in the country.

The compromise passed Wednesday adopts Brown’s $315 million proposal, but, on the chance that the three-judge-panel currently driving the state’s prison population bus allows for an extension of the Dec. 31 deadline, the first $75 million saved from Brown’s plan would go into the state’s “Recidivism Reduction Fund,” with additional funds added if prison capacity costs don’t increase.

Notwithstanding a quibbling debate over what level of double-celling, dormitory-dumping, sardine-packing should be considered a humane level of punitive confinement, and where those now-illegally-congested bodies should be sent, none of this addresses the real issue of California prison overcrowding

© The Sonoma Index Tribune  |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments
Switch to our Mobile View